Sunset Beach, Shelter Island Heights

Sunset Beach seems to have lost its charm over the years. While the beautiful surroundings and the party atmosphere were enjoyable, the hotel itself left much to be desired. The service was inconsistent, with some staff being dismissive, and there were significant issues with room maintenance and amenities. Overall, it feels overpriced for what you receive, and expectations certainly weren't met.

Sunset Beach offers a laid-back vibe and beautiful scenery on Shelter Island, making it a unique place to unwind. However, my experience was marred by a lack of dining options and some service inconsistencies. While my daughter loved the ambiance, I felt the accommodations didn't quite match the price tag.

I had a mix of experiences at Sunset Beach. The location is beautiful, and the beach staff were delightful and really made our time enjoyable. However, the hotel itself is in need of serious upgrades, especially with the lack of dining options available during our stay which was really frustrating. The cost is quite high for what you actually get, which made us question the value. Overall, it's a uniquely laid-back place, but not without its shortcomings.

My stay at Sunset Beach had its ups and downs. The location on Shelter Island is picturesque, and the relaxed vibe is definitely a plus. However, the dining options were quite limited, and the room was nothing to rave about given the price. Still, I enjoyed the friendly beach staff and the vibrant atmosphere that comes alive in the evenings.

Our stay at Sunset Beach was a mixed bag. The beach was lovely, and we enjoyed the relaxed atmosphere. However, we encountered significant issues with the dining options and overall service, which really put a damper on our experience. The hotel's charm lies in its non-pretentious vibe but be prepared for some frustrations, especially around mealtimes.